Chris Carpenter

Photo credit: Rob Carr, Getty Images

October 7, 2011: The Carpenter vs Halladay Game

The St. Louis Cardinals squared off against the Philadelphia Phillies in a playoff pitching duel that is still talked about today, and will be for some time.

The Cardinals forced this deciding game 5 by coming from behind to beat the Phillies in game 4. They trailed 2-0 after the top of the first inning, but then rallied to win 5-3. David Freese had a 2-run double in the 4th inning, and a 2-run home run in the 6th. That was the famous “rally squirrel” game.

Rafael Furcal led off the game. He worked a 2-1 count and then hit a triple to right-center field. The next batter was Skip Schumaker. He had the best at bat of the game for either team. He quickly got into an 0-2 hole. He then fouled off four pitches and took two more for balls. On the 10th pitch of the at-bat, he doubled into the corner to score Furcal. It was the only run scored the entire game.

Halladay then settled down and started dominating. He threw 8 innings total, and only allowed 4 more hits after those first two batters. He struck out 7 and walked 1.

As brilliant as he was, Chris Carpenter out-dueled him. Carpenter threw a complete game shutout. He only allowed 3 hits, and no walks. Oddly, he only struck out 3 batters. He threw 110 pitches in the gem.

The Phillies threatened in the bottom of the fourth when Carpneter hit the leadoff batter with a pitch. Shane Victorino singled with two outs. The two runners were stranded when Carpenter got Raul Ibanez to flyout.

Victorino had also doubled in the second inning and was stranded. The only other Phillies hit was a single by Utley in the bottom of the 6th inning, but Utley was caught stealing.

The game ended with Ryan Howard grounding out to the second baseman. Howard injured his Achilles’ tendon coming out of the batter’s box and was unable to run to first. Howard ended up missing the next season as well recovering from the injury. It was a brutal way to end such a great game, even if you are a Cardinals fan.

You can watch the entire game here: